Early appearances (2017–2018)

Before being officially signed to Impact Wrestling, Miguel competed in a few "tryout" matches. The first being on the August 20, 2017, episode of Impact!, teaming with Jon Bolen where they lost to Ohio Versus Everything (Jake and Dave Crist). The latter being Miguel's trainer and the guy who helped break him into the company. On the September 6, 2018 episode of Impact!, Miguel made his second appearance by teaming with Zachary Wentz and Ace Austin as enhancement talents again against Ohio Versus Everything (Dave Crist, Jake Crist, and Sami Callihan) in a losing effort.^[8]

The Rascalz (2018–2020)

A vignette aired promoting the debut of Rascalz on the November 15 episode of Impact!.^[9] On the November 29 episode of Impact!, Miguel made his official debut alongside Dezmond Xavier and Zachary Wentz as the trio known as The Rascalz, accompanying them ringside when Xavier and Wentz competed in a tag team match against Chris Bey and Mike Sydal.^[10] In mid-2019, Trey and the Rascalz began a feud against Moose, which led to all the Rascalz making their pay-per-view debut against Moose and The North (Ethan Page and Josh Alexander) in a six-man tag team match at Rebellion, which Rascalz lost. During the match, the ring names of Xavier, Miguel and Wentz were shortened to Dez, Trey and Wentz respectively.

On the November 13, 2019, episode of Impact, Trey became the number one contender for the X Division Championship by pinning Petey Williams in a six-way match, but failed to win the title from Ace Austin at Hard to Kill.^[11] At Slammiversary, Trey received his first shot at the vacant Impact World Championship in a five-way elimination match against Ace Austin, Eddie Edwards, Rich Swann, and the returning Eric Young, but was eliminated first by Young.^[12] On November 11, it was revealed that The Rascalz would soon be leaving Impact and had interest from both WWE and All Elite Wrestling. During the November 17 tapings, The Rascalz were given a "send-off" by the Impact locker room. Trey confirmed the following day that he, Dez and Wentz were in fact done appearing on Impact Wrestling. Dez and Wentz went on to sign with WWE while Trey remained a free agent.

X Division Champion (2021–2023)

Trey made a surprise return to Impact on the January 26, 2021, episode of Impact, teaming with Tommy Dreamer, Rich Swann, and Willie Mack to defeat Chris Bey, Moose, Ken Shamrock, and Sami Callihan.^[13] During his return match, his ring name was reverted to Trey Miguel. Shortly after his return, Miguel began a heated high level feud with Callihan based on Callihan's theory that Miguel couldn't survive without Dez and Wentz. Throughout the deeply personal feud, Miguel would get tormented by Callihan in many ways including being forced to watch his trainee Sam Beale get beat down and be constantly told he "lost his passion". After weeks of back and forth attacks and mind games, the feud culminated in a last man standing match at Rebellion, which Miguel won.^[14]

In September, Miguel entered a tournament to determine a new X Division Champion, where he defeated Alex Zayne and Laredo Kid in the first round.^[15] At Bound for Glory, Miguel defeated El Phantasmo and Steve Maclin in the final to win the Impact X Division Championship.^[16][17] On the October 28 episode of Impact!, Miguel made his first successful title defense against New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW) talent Rocky Romero.^[18] Miguel then retained his title against Laredo Kid and Steve Maclin at Turning Point,^[19] against Maclin at Hard To Kill,^[20] and against Jake Something at Sacrifice.^[21] On April 1, 2022, at Multiverse of Matches, Miguel successfully defended his X Division Championship against Blake Christian, Chris Bey, Jordynne Grace, Rich Swann, and Vincent in an Intergender Ultimate X match.^[22] At Rebellion, he lost the title to Ace Austin in a three-way match involving Mike Bailey, ending his reign at 182 days.^[23] Two weeks later, he failed to regain the title in a rematch at Under Siege.^[24]

On the May 12 episode of Impact!, Miguel competed in a Gauntlet for the Gold to determine the number one contender to Josh Alexander's Impact World Championship at Slammiversary, but was eliminated by Steve Maclin.^[25] On the May 26 episode of Impact!, Miguel defeated Alex Shelley to qualify for the Ultimate X match for the X Division Championship at Slammiversary.^[26] At the event, he failed to capture the title that was won by Mike Bailey.^[27] On the June 30 episode of Impact!, Miguel won a four-way match to get a shot at the X Division title.^[28] A day later, at Against All Odds, he failed to beat Bailey for the title.^[29]

On September 23, at Victory Road, Miguel competed in an Intergender Triple Threat Revolver to determine the number one contender for the X Division Championship, but was eliminated by eventual winner Frankie Kazarian.^[30] He later took part in a tournament to crown a new X Division Champion, defeating Alan Angels in the quarterfinals and Mike Bailey in the semifinals.^[31][32] On November 18, at Over Drive, Miguel defeated Black Taurus in the final by turning heel after blinding him with spray paint, and won the vacant title for a second time.^[33] On the December 1 episode of Impact!, Miguel explained what he needed to do to regain the title and sprayed green paint on it.^[34] On January 13, 2023, on the Countdown to Hard to Kill pre-show, Miguel defeated Taurus to successfully retain his title.^[35] He continued to retain the X Division title on Impact! against Mike Jackson,^[36] and against Crazzy Steve in a Monster's Ball match.^[37] Miguel followed that with more successful defenses against Lince Dorado at Sacrifice,^[38] against Clark Connors, Frankie Kazarian, Kevin Knight, Rich Swann, and Rocky Romero in a six-way scramble match at Multiverse United,^[39] against Jonathan Gresham and Mike Bailey in a three-way elimination match at Rebellion^[40] and against Chris Sabin at Under Siege.^[41] On June 9 at Against All Odds, Miguel lost the X Division Championship to Sabin, ending his reign at 203 days.^[42]

The Rascalz reunion (2023–present)

On the June 29, 2023, episode of Impact, Miguel had a rematch against Chris Sabin for the X Division Championship which ended in a no-contest when Zachary Wentz made his return and attacked the latter, thus reuniting the Rascalz as villains in the process.^[43] On July 23, 2023 at Impact Wrestling Pay-per-view Emergence of year 2023 Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz won the Impact World Tag Team Championship for the first time in their careers for their team The Rascalz by defeating Mark Andrews & Flash Morgan Webster, Subculture.^[44] On October 21 at Bound for Glory, Miguel and Wentz lost the Impact World Tag Team Championships to ABC (Ace Austin & Chris Bey), ending their reign at 55 days.^[45]