# | Year | Name(s); * = reordination |
1 | July 1862 | Joseph Astin, Alexander Bickerton, Arthur Bickerton, Thomas Bickerton, James Brown, William Cadman, Sr.; Cummings Cherry, John Dixon, Joseph Knox, Benjamin Meadowcroft, John Neish, James Nichols |
2 | January 1863 | George Barnes, Charles Brown |
3 | July 1863 | William Bickerton |
4 | July 1865 | William Bacon, William Skillen |
5 | January 1870 | Andrew Rattray |
6 | July 1873 | James Louttit |
7 | July 1904 | J. L. Armbrust, William H. Cadman, Marion Campbell, Alexander Cherry, Thomas Dixon, William Lynch, William T. Maxwell, James Skillen, Thornton Welch, John Williams, Allen Wright |
8 | July 1905 | Solomon Van Lieu |
9 | July 1906 | William Helms |
10 | July 1907 | Francis Federer, Nephi Federer, John Grimes, Charles Tickhill |
11 | July 1908 | Robert Anderson, Charles Ashton, Gustave Blum, Alma Cadman |
12 | July 1909 | James Caldwell |
13 | July 1910 | John Penn |
14 | July 1911 | Vernon Chester, John Majoros |
15 | October 1911 | George Neill, Isaac Smith |
16 | April 1912 | Samuel Sanders, Fred Smith, John Ward |
17 | July 1914 | Herman Kennedy, Harry Nicholson |
18 | October 1917 | Thurman Furnier |
19 | Circa 1918 | James C. Cowan |
20 | July 1919 | Gustave Bloom *, E. J. Perry |
21 | August 1923 | Charles Behanna, Joseph Corrado, Martin King, Ishmael D'Amico |
22 | July 1925 | Alma Cadman * |
23 | July 1931 | Isaac Smith * |
24 | April 1934 | John Falola, Sr. |
25 | July 1934 | John Dulisse |
26 | July 1939 | Rocco Biscotti, Joseph Lovalvo |
27 | July 1941 | Angelo Antonio Corrado, Samuel Kirschner, V. James Lovalvo |
28 | January 1944 | James C. Cowan* |
29 | January 1948 | Charles Behanna* |
30 | April 1953 | Joseph Bittinger, Paul D'Amico |
31 | April 1956 | Russell Cadman, Gorie Ciaravino, William Gennaro |
32 | April 1964 | Frank Calabrese, Dominic Thomas |
33 | May 1974 | Nick Pietrangelo |
34 | April 1979 | Robert A. Watson |
35 | October 1986 | Paul Palmieri |
36 | April 1989 | Paul Benyola, Joseph Calabrese |
37 | October 1995 | Thomas M. Liberto |
38 | October 1997 | Peter Scolaro, Isaac Smith |
39 | October 2003 | Richard T. Christman, John R. Griffith |
40 | April 2005 | Paul Liberto, Philip R. Jackson |
41 | April 2007 | Leonard A. Lovalvo |
42 | October 2007 | James Crudup |
43 | October 2012 | Joel Gehly |
44 | October 2015 | Frank Natoli, Paul Aaron Palmieri |
45 | April 2018 | Jerry Valenti |
46 | October 2021 | Pete Giannetti, Scott Griffith |