BDO

In August 2010, McGeeney won the Weoley Castle Open, beating Kevin Taylor in the final. In September 2014, he won the England Classic; he beat Sam Hewson in the quarter-final before beating Wesley Harms in the final. In April 2015, McGeeney won the Lincolnshire Open by beating Joshua Richardson in the Final. In September 2015, he won the British Open beating Scott Waites in the final.

McGeeney reached back-to-back Winmau World Masters finals, losing to Glen Durrant and Krzysztof Ratajski in 2016 and 2017 respectively, and won the Dutch Open.

In 2018, after two previous 2nd round losses, McGeeney reached the final of the BDO World Darts Championship against Durrant. McGeeney came from 6–4 down in sets to lead 2–0 in the decider, but eventually lost 7–6. He became only the second player in World Championship history after Mike Gregory in 1992 to miss championship darts (one at D18 and one at D9) and lose the match. The following month, McGeeney retained his Dutch Open title, beating Durrant 3–1 in sets in the final.

In 2019, at his last appearance at a BDO World Championship McGeeney was once again knocked out in the 2nd round.

PDC

McGeeney revealed in December 2018 that he will compete in the Professional Darts Corporation's Q-School in 2019, due to new rules that allow unsuccessful Q-School competitors to compete within the BDO.^[1] After losing out in the final to Harry Ward 5–2 on the first day, he recovered to go all the way on day two, beating Carl Wilkinson 5–4 in the final to seal a two-year PDC Tour Card.

McGeeney is currently at risk of losing his PDC tour card at the end of 2021 having not managed to find his form since moving across from BDO, and as a result not making the top 64 to secure an extension, he is yet to announce if he intends to return to Q-School in 2022.

BDO

• 2016: 2nd round (lost to Scott Mitchell 3–4)
• 2017: 2nd round (lost to Scott Waites 2–4)
• 2018: Runner-up (lost to Glen Durrant 6–7)
• 2019: 2nd round (lost to Conan Whitehead 0–4)

PDC

• 2020: 2nd round (lost to Ricky Evans 1–3)

BDO major finals: 3 (3 runner-up)

More information Outcome, No. ...

Outcome	No.	Year	Championship	Opponent in the final	Score[N 1]
Runner-up	1.	2016	Winmau World Masters	Glen Durrant	3–6 (s)
Runner-up	2.	2017	Winmau World Masters	Krzysztof Ratajski	1–6 (s)
Runner-up	3.	2018	World Darts Championship	Glen Durrant	6–7 (s)

Close