Independent circuit (2005–2020)

On September 17, 2005 for Pro Wrestling Evolution, Konley made his debut under the ring name Black Pegasus.^[3]

In the fall of 2019 he began appearing on the National Wrestling Alliance's NWA Power YouTube series under the name Caleb Konley. On the March 3 edition of Power, Konley and his tag team partner C. W. Anderson defeated the Dawson's to win contracts with the NWA.^[4]

Total Nonstop Action Wrestling / Impact Wrestling (2016–2022)

In April 2016, Konley made his Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA) debut at Impact tapings, facing both Eddie Edwards^[5] and DJZ^[6] in losing efforts for Xplosion. On April 29, TNA officially announced Konley's signing to the company.^[7] Konley would make his last appearance as a contracted wrestler at One Night Only: X-Travaganza, where Konley once again faced off against Edwards in a losing effort.^[8] In March 2017, Burnett began working under a mask as the newest incarnation of the Suicide character.^[9]

On August 17, 2017, at Destination X: Impact, Konley would interfere on behalf of Trevor Lee in the X Division Championship match against Sonjay Dutt, forming an alliance and turning heel in the process.^[10] In the coming weeks, Konley would go on to change his attire to simple black trunks, mirroring Trevor Lee's look. On the October 5 episode of Impact!, Konley, Lee and Andrew Everett would face Sonjay Dutt, Petey Williams, and Matt Sydal in a losing effort in a six-man tag team match.^[11] On January 1, 2019, Trevor Lee left Impact Wrestling, disbanding the team.^[12] On January 26, 2019, his profile was moved to the alumni section. On March 1, 2019, Konley announced on his Twitter that he had officially become a free agent.^[13]

On the September 8, 2020, episode of Impact, Konley made his return to Impact under the name Kaleb with a K debuting a new gimmick of Tenille Dashwood's personal photographer.^[14][15] On April 14, 2022, Konley announced his departure from Impact Wrestling.^[16][17]