Year | Winner | Score | Loser | MVP | Host | Host arena |
1993[4] |
East All-Stars | 7–3 | West All-Stars | Darren Schwartz, Wheeling (East) | Wheeling Thunderbirds | Wheeling Civic Center |
1994[5] |
West All-Stars | 7–6 | East All-Stars | Joe Cook, Columbus (West) Cory Cadden, Knoxville (West) | Hampton Roads Admirals | Norfolk Scope |
1995[6] |
West All-Stars | 6–5 | East All-Stars | Jay Neal, Toledo (West) | Greensboro Monarchs | Greensboro Coliseum |
1996[7] |
Northern Conference | 10–7 | Southern Conference | Don Parsons, Johnstown (North) | Tallahassee Tiger Sharks | Tallahassee-Leon County Civic Center |
1997[8] |
Charlotte Checkers | 7–6 | ECHL All-Stars | Andrei Bashkirov, Huntington (ECHL) David Brosseau, Charlotte | Charlotte Checkers | Independence Arena |
1998[9] |
Canada All-Stars | 11–7 | USA/World All-Stars | Thomas Braun, Jacksonville (Canada) | Louisiana IceGators | Cajundome |
1999[10] |
Southern Conference | 7–4 | Northern Conference | Jason Elders, Mobile (South) | Mississippi Sea Wolves | Mississippi Coast Coliseum |
2000[11] |
Northern Conference | 8–6 | Southern Conference | Jeff Mitchell, Dayton (North) | Greenville Grrrowl | BI-LO Center |
2001[12] |
Southern Conference | 9–5 | Northern Conference | Jonas Soling, Augusta (South) | Arkansas RiverBlades | ALLTEL Arena |
2002[13] |
Southern Conference | 7–6 | Northern Conference | Allan Sirois, Augusta (South) | Trenton Titans | Sovereign Bank Arena |
2003[14] |
Northern Conference | 8–2 | Southern Conference | Scott Stirling, Atlantic City (North) | Florida Everblades | Germain Arena |
2004[15] |
Eastern Conference | 7–6 | Western Conference | Randy Rowe, Peoria (East) | Peoria Rivermen | Carver Arena |
2005[16] |
National Conference | 6–2 | American Conference | Frank Doyle, Idaho (National) | Reading Royals | Sovereign Center |
2006[17] |
National Conference | 7–6 | American Conference | Luke Curtin, Fresno (National) | Fresno Falcons | Save Mart Center |
2007[18] |
American Conference | 6–3 | National Conference | Adam Berkhoel, Dayton (American) | Idaho Steelheads | Qwest Arena |
2008[19] |
National Conference | 10–7 | American Conference | Ash Goldie, Victoria (National) | Stockton Thunder | Stockton Arena |
2009[20] |
American Conference | 11–5 | National Conference | Matt Ford, Charlotte (American) | Reading Royals | Sovereign Center |
2010[21] |
National Conference | 10–9 | American Conference | Evan Barlow, Idaho (National) | Ontario Reign | Citizens Business Bank Arena |
2011[22] |
ECHL All Stars | 9–3 | Bakersfield Condors | Mark Arcobello, Stockton (ECHL All Stars) | Bakersfield Condors | Rabobank Arena |
2012[1] |
No All-Star Game scheduled |
2013[23][24] |
ECHL All Stars | 7–3 | Colorado Eagles | Ryan Zapolski, South Carolina (ECHL All Stars) | Colorado Eagles | Budweiser Events Center |
2014 |
No All-Star Game scheduled |
2015 |
ECHL All Stars | 8–4 | Orlando Solar Bears | Myles Bell, Evansville (ECHL All Stars) | Orlando Solar Bears | Amway Center |
2016[25] |
No All-Star Game scheduled |
2017[26] |
ECHL All Stars | 8–7 | Adirondack Thunder | Matt Garbowsky, Colorado (ECHL All Stars) | Adirondack Thunder | Glens Falls Civic Center |
2018[2] |
Mountain Division | 6–5 (SO) | South Division | Taylor Cammarata, South Carolina (South Div.) | Indy Fuel | Indiana Farmers Coliseum |
2019[27][28] |
Eastern Conference | 2–1 (SO) | Team Fins | David Pacan, Brampton (Eastern Conf.) | Toledo Walleye | Huntington Center |
2020[29] |
Eastern Conference | 4–2 | Western Conference | Logan Roe, Florida (Eastern Conf.) | Wichita Thunder | Intrust Bank Arena |
2021[30] |
ECHL All-Star Game not held due to COVID-19 pandemic, 2021 host awarded the 2022 event | Jacksonville Icemen | VyStar Veterans Memorial Arena |
2022[31][32] |
ECHL All-Stars | 14–7 | Jacksonville Icemen | Marcus Crawford, Kansas City (All-Stars) | Jacksonville Icemen | VyStar Veterans Memorial Arena |
2023[33] |
Destroyers | 2-0 | Norfolk Admirals | | Norfolk Admirals | Norfolk Scope |
2024[34] |
ECHL All-Stars | 18-11 | Savannah Ghost Pirates | | Savannah Ghost Pirates | Enmarket Arena |