The school's athletic teams compete in the Dairyland Conference.[3]
The C-FC Pirates' cross-country team was the Wisconsin Division 3 boys' state champion four consecutive years, from 1993 to 1996, and girls' state champion in 1996, 1998, and 1999.[citation needed]
The C-FC Pirates' saw success in volleyball as well. From the 2008 season to the 2017 season, the Pirates won ten consecutive girls' volleyball conference championships, with the seasons of 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017 all being undefeated in the Dairyland.
In those 10 seasons, the girl's volleyball team went an impressive 82-2 in conference play.
The girls' softball team has won four consecutive conference championships, from 2009 to 2012. They continued the streak starting in 2014 and have taken the 2015, 2016 and 2017 seasons. In June 2014, the girls’ softball team made their first Division 4 state appearance, taking second place after losing to Oakfield.[4] They made a second state appearance in the 2016 season.[5]
In March 2014, the C-FC Pirates' made their first appearance for state Division 5 Boys basketball tournament at the Kohl Center, in Madison, Wisconsin.[6]
In fall of 2023, Cochrane-Fountain City became the first school in Division 3 to have a state champion in both the boys and girls division. 2023 graduate, Wesley Pronschinske, won the boys' Division 3 boys individual crown with a time of 16:08.9.[7] 2026 graduate, Addy Duellman, won the individual girls' Division 3 title with a time of 18:58.1.[8] The 2023 season also marked the schools' 4th gold medal for the Division 3 Girls' since 1999. They won the gold medal in Division 3 with a team score of 132 points.[9]
