September–December

The club's first match of the season, on 2 September, was away to Queens Park Rangers; Floyd, Phillips, Sheridan and Marriott all made their Southern League debuts for New Brompton.^[13] Queens Park Rangers scored two goals in each half to win 4–0; the correspondent for The Daily News stated that the home team were "the better side at every point" and well deserved their large victory.^[14] The first Southern League game of the season at New Brompton's ground, Priestfield Road, a week later against Bristol Rovers, resulted in a 3–0 win for the away team.^[13][15] Phillips scored New Brompton's first Southern League goal of the season on 16 September and the team achieved their first victory, beating Northampton Town 2–0,^[13][16] before losing again in their next game, a 4–0 defeat away to Portsmouth.^[17] After a goalless draw with Swindon Town, New Brompton were 15th out of 18 teams in the Division One table at the end of September.^[18]

On 7 October, New Brompton lost 5–0 away to Millwall, the first time the team had conceded as many goals in a Southern League match since December 1903.^[19] Two weeks later, they failed to score a goal for the sixth time in eight Southern League games and were defeated 6–0 by Tottenham Hotspur, the team's biggest defeat of the season. The correspondent for the Daily Telegraph said that New Brompton had been "completely outplay[ed]".^[20][21] The team ended the month with their second Southern League victory of the season, a 2–1 win over Brentford. The first match of November, however, resulted in another defeat as New Brompton lost 4–1 to Norwich City;^[13] the result left New Brompton 16th in the table. Their record of having conceded 28 goals in 10 games was by far the worst in the division; no other team had conceded more than 20 and only one other had conceded more than 16.^[22] The team's winless run continued for the rest of the month as they drew with Plymouth Argyle and Southampton and lost to Reading.^[13] John Campbell, a former Scottish international forward newly signed from Hibernian,^[23][24] made his debut against Reading.^[13]

New Brompton began December with a game away to Watford; they twice took the lead only for Watford to equalise and the game ended in a draw.^[25] The team lost their next two games, away to West Ham United and at home to Fulham.^[13] On Christmas Day, New Brompton beat Brighton & Hove Albion 1–0; Campbell scored the winner from a penalty kick, his first goal for the club.^[13] New Brompton ended 1905 with a 2–0 home defeat to Queens Park Rangers; John Martin, normally a full-back, played as goalkeeper in place of Fred Griffiths. The Athletic News referred to this as a trial arrangement, but Martin retained the position for most of the remainder of the season.^[13][26] The reporter for the Athletic News wrote that on the whole New Brompton played as well as their opponents but that their forwards "proved quite incapable of turning to account the many openings which fell their way".^[26]

January–April

New Brompton's first Southern League game of 1906 was away to Bristol Rovers, who were reduced to ten men before half-time when their goalkeeper went off injured. For the second time in three games, Campbell scored the winning goal with a penalty kick.^[13][27] The team next beat Northampton Town, the only time during the season that they won two consecutive Southern League games.^[13] New Brompton's next game drew an attendance reported at 5,500, the largest of the season at Priestfield Road; the Athletic News attributed the large turnout to "the recent smart performances of the local eleven".^[28] The match, however, ended in the first of two consecutive 1–0 defeats for New Brompton.^[13]

The team's winless Southern League run extended to four games with defeats away to Luton Town on 17 February and Brentford on 3 March.^[13] New Brompton then defeated Tottenham Hotspur, who were second in the league table ahead of the game,^[29] at Priestfield Road. Paddy Travers scored the only goal to give his team what the Daily Telegraph's reporter described as their best result of the season; the writer praised the New Brompton defence as "very sound".^[30] After this victory, the team played five more games in March and failed to score in any of them.^[31] After a goalless draw at home to Norwich City, they lost 5–0 away to Plymouth Argyle. According to the Athletic News, New Brompton were "quite outclassed" by Plymouth and "had [Plymouth] doubled the number of their goals they would have occasioned little surprise".^[32] Three further defeats left New Brompton bottom of the table at the end of March.^[31][33] Goalkeeper Harry Metherell, who had played one Southern League game two years earlier but not been included in the team since, was included in the line-up against Reading and retained his place for the rest of the season.^[19]

After five games without scoring, New Brompton defeated Watford 2–0 in the first match of April.^[34] Their next two games resulted in goalless draws against Brighton & Hove Albion and West Ham United;^[13] the Athletic News was again critical of New Brompton's forwards against West Ham, saying that the team's "lack of success was mainly due to the inability of their front line to accept the gifts which the fortune of the game offered".^[35] New Brompton's final game of the season was away to Fulham, who had already clinched the championship of Division One,^[36] and resulted in a 1–0 defeat.^[13] New Brompton finished the season 17th out of 18 teams in the league table, above only Northampton Town.^[37] The team had failed to score in eight of the last nine games of the Southern League season;^[13] the final total of 20 league goals was half the figure recorded in the previous season and the lowest figure New Brompton had registered in 12 seasons of competitive football.^[38]

Match details

Key

Partial league table

Match details

Key

Results^[13]