Conception

Bill Maynard had the initial idea for the show, wishing to create a sitcom based around the members of the working men's club in his home village of Sapcote, Leicestershire.^[3] He later said "every character came from that club".^[3] Maynard modelled his lead character on Peter Wright, a larger-than-life patron who often exclaimed "magic!" with his thumbs up and ordered "a pint of cooking and a bag of nuts", both of which would become catchphrases of Maynard's character.^[4][5][1] Wright had arms too muscular to fold properly so he kept them high on his chest, another attribute Maynard borrowed.^[3] Maynard later commented "you couldn't dream up a character like Selwyn. In fact, I played him down."^[6] Additionally, Maynard took inspiration from Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, with Froggitt as Bottom and the committee at the working men's club as the mechanicals.^[7][8] Robert Keegan believed Maynard based Selwyn "on himself".^[9]

Maynard considered Froggitt's interest in reading The Times an important part of the character, explaining "I wanted him to be intelligent, always anxious to improve himself. The easy route would've been to use old clichés, like malapropisms and spoonerisms, but that would have made the character too one-dimensional. By getting him to read The Times and be an ardent student of dynamic word power, we gave him the breadth to spread the comedy over a wide range of subjects. We wanted people to laugh with him, not at him".^[10] Maynard characterised Froggitt as someone who causes havoc simply due to "his tremendous enthusiasm and his willingness to help his fellow man", rather than "an idiot".^[11] He identified "a lot of drama and a certain amount of pathos" in the character.^[11]

Commission and writing

Maynard attempted to get the programme commissioned by Duncan Wood during the latter's 1972–73 tenure as the BBC's Head of Comedy.^[10] Wood commissioned a pilot after he had moved to Yorkshire Television to be Head of Light Entertainment.^[12] Wood brought in Roy Clarke, the creator of Last of the Summer Wine, to write the pilot for the series. As Clarke felt he lacked the familiarity to write about a working men's club, Maynard took the train to Leeds to assist him. Clarke devised the title Oh No It's Selwyn Froggitt, and the pilot episode was transmitted on 30 September 1974 as part of a six-week season of Yorkshire Television comedy specials.^[10][13] This initial episode rendered Selwyn's surname as 'Froggit'.^[14]

The first series of Oh No It's Selwyn Froggitt was commissioned in September 1975, following the failure of another sitcom starring Maynard, The Life of Riley.^[15] Feeling the pilot had been at odds with his original concept, the actor met again with Clarke to discuss the show's direction. According to Maynard, Clarke admitted he had found it difficult to write about situations he had not thought up himself and decided he was not right for the job.^[10] Maynard approached Alan Plater to take Clarke's place as writer, having worked with the playwright and screenwriter on Trinity Tales (1975).^[10] Plater was best known for writing television dramas including Shoulder to Shoulder (1974) and The Stars Look Down (1975); Oh No It's Selwyn Froggitt was his only foray into sitcom writing. Plater's involvement has been characterised as indicative of a maverick and prolific approach to television writing.^[16] He would later comment that Maynard had "a constitutional resistance to learning the script".^[16]

The second series episode "Daze of Hope", in which Selwyn believes he is to feature in an episode of This Is Your Life with Eamonn Andrews, was inspired by Maynard's own experience on the programme in 1974.^[10] The series employed little bawdy humour; Maynard said he received letters thanking him for "the cleanest show on television".^[11]

Filming and transmission

Filming for the first series commenced in October 1975.^[17] It was mainly shot at Yorkshire Television Studios on Kirkstall Road, Leeds, whilst outdoor location filming for the series took place in Skelmanthorpe, West Yorkshire and Elvington, North Yorkshire.^[17] Bill Maynard's wife Muriel frequently attended dress rehearsals and recordings.^[10] Megs Jenkins, cast as Froggitt's mother, had initially considered herself the wrong fit for the role and resolved to approach the part straight.^[18] The programme's theme tune was written and composed by Bill Dean, who starred as Jack, and performed by the Tony Mansell Singers.^[19] The theme would feature different lyrics for each episode.^[19] On transmission, the series became a ratings success, topping the national weekly chart and eventually reaching peak viewing figures of 29 million.^[4][20] Froggitt became a cult figure, with his catchphrase "magic!" and thumbs-up becoming widely known in the United Kingdom.^[21][22]

Rosemary Martin, who played Maurice Froggitt's partner Vera, left the programme after its first series. Interviewed in July 1976, she stated "I was sick of playing silly, mindless women. And Selwyn Froggitt, although a very successful show, was one of the unhappiest jobs I have ever had. I left it thinking I must be a quarrelsome, bad tempered person who couldn't get on with anybody."^[23] Martin was replaced by Lynda Baron, who had recently appeared as Nurse Gladys Emmanuel in the first series of Open All Hours.^[24][25]

The second series topped the national ratings for four of the seven weeks it was on air.^[26] Interviewed during its run, Maynard described the second series as the last, saying the Froggitt role was "starting to take me over".^[27] Maynard was uncomfortable with the prospect of being typecast and refused to appear in character as Selwyn for public appearances.^[28][29] When starring in a pantomime production of Jack and the Beanstalk in Norwich, Maynard insisted his character be called "Simple Simon" rather than the scripted "Simple Selwyn".^[29] Maynard was signed to Waif Records as a singer and turned down several songs with Froggitt's catchphrase "magic" in the title.^[29] After the programme ended, Maynard wrote "Stock Car Racing is Magic", a self-released single credited to Vroom.^[30]

The immense popularity of Oh No It's Selwyn Froggitt led to the commissioning of a third series by June 1977.^[26] Alan Plater, who described both himself and Maynard as "knackered" after the previous run, agreed to return but only to write two episodes.^[26] Filming commenced on 5 September 1977, following Maynard's recovery from a slipped disc.^[31] A Christmas episode, "On the Feast of Selwyn", concluded the third series.^[32]

Maynard had considered the third series the last, but was persuaded by Duncan Wood to return for a new version of the programme, simply titled Selwyn.^[29] Maynard believed the programme had got into a rut and considered a new setting and supporting cast the best way to further develop his character.^[33] Maynard drew on his 1950s experience as a comedian at Butlin's for the holiday camp setting.^[10] Plater was not involved with this fourth series and Robert Keegan, who had played Maurice, considered the removal of the supporting cast a potential mistake "as I think viewers of situation comedy like to get to know lots of characters".^[33] A proposed fifth series was not produced after disappointing audience reactions.^[2] Maynard confirmed the series had finished in May 1980, telling the media "if you keep on with the same character all the time, people won't accept you as anything else. If I do [play Selwyn again], it will be when people have begun to forget about him."^[34][35]

Pilot (1974)

The pilot and the first series were released on DVD by Network on 25 May 2009.

Series 1 (1976)

Series 2 (1977)

The second series was released on DVD by Network on 7 September 2009.

Series 3 (1977)

The third series was released on DVD by Network on 3 May 2010.

Series 4 (1978)

The fourth series was released on DVD by Network on 16 August 2010.