Player | Position | Seasons | Notes | Ref |
Ed Andrews | LF | 1891 | Andrews was the starting left fielder, and batted .211 in 83 games played. | [4] |
Charlie Bastian | 2B | 1891 | Bastian played 1 game at second base. | [5] |
Charlie Bell | SP | 1891 | Bell pitched 1 game for the Killers, a complete game win, and collected 2 hits in 4 at bats. It was his last game in the major leagues. | [6] |
Joe Burke | 2B | 1891 | Burke played 1 game at second base, his last game in the major leagues. | [7] |
Jim Canavan | SS | 1891 | Canavan led the team with 101 games played, as well several hitting categories, such as: runs scored, triples, home runs, and RBIs. | [3][8] |
John Carney | 1B | 1891 | Carney played first base, and batted .278 in 99 games played. When the Killers folded, he played for the Milwaukee Brewers, his last season in the major leagues. | [9] |
Billy Clingman | 2B | 1891 | Clingman played 1 game at second base. | [10] |
Ed Crane | SP | 1891 | Crane pitched in 32 games, and had a win–loss record of 14–14, and a 2.45 earned run average. | [11] |
Frank Dwyer | SP | 1891 | Dwyer pitched in 35 games, and had a win–loss record of 13–19, and a 4.52 earned run average. | [12] |
Jerry Hurley | C | 1891 | Hurley played in 24 games, and had a .212 batting average. It was his last season at the major league level. | [13] |
Dick Johnston | CF | 1891 | Johnston had 6 home runs, 51 RBIs, and a .212 batting average in 1891, his last season in the major leagues. | [14] |
Kid Keenan | SP | 1891 | Keenan pitched 1 game for the Killers, a complete game loss, and collected 2 hits in 4 at bats. It was his only game in the major leagues. | [15] |
King Kelly† § | C / IF | 1891 | Kelly was the catcher and manager for the Kilers. He played in 82 games, and batted .297. He finished the season with the Boston Reds, also of the AA. | [16] |
Matt Kilroy | SP | 1891 | Kilroy pitched in 8 games, and had a win–loss record of 1–4, and a 2.98 earned run average. | [17] |
Willard Mains | SP / RP | 1891 | Mains pitched in 30 games, and had a win–loss record of 12–12, and a 2.69 earned run average. | [18] |
Lefty Marr | RF | 1891 | Marr played in 14 games, and batted .248. It was the last season he played in the major leagues. | [19] |
Willie McGill | SP | 1891 | McGill pitched in 8 games, and had a win–loss record of 2–55, and a 4.98 earned run average. | [20] |
Yank Robinson | 2B | 1891 | Robinson played all his 97 games at second base, and had a .178 batting average. | [21] |
Emmett Seery | RF | 1891 | Seery played in 97 games, and had a .285 batting average. | [22] |
John Slagle | RP | 1891 | Slagle pitched in 1 games, an inning and a third of relief. He allowed no runs to score. | [23] |
Farmer Vaughn | C | 1891 | Vaughn played in 55 games, and had a .257 batting average. | [24] |
Art Whitney | 3B | 1891 | Whitney played in 97 games, and had a .199 batting average. | [25] |
Wild Bill Widner | SP | 1891 | Widner pitched 1 game for the Killers, a complete game loss, and collected 1 hits in 4 at bats. It was his last game in the major leagues. | [26] |