August–December

Gillingham's first match of the season was at their home ground, Priestfield Stadium, against Chesterfield. Both Smillie and Micklewhite made their debuts in a game which finished 2–0 to Gillingham's opponents;^[15][16] a week later the team again lost without scoring a goal, losing 3–0 away to Rochdale.^[17] Gillingham's next five league games all ended in draws; Paul Baker scored the team's first league goal in the first of these games, a 2–2 draw at home to Scarborough.^[17] Steve Banks, a 21-year old goalkeeper who had joined the club five months earlier, made his debut in the following game at home to Doncaster Rovers, replacing the previous season's regular goalkeeper, Scott Barrett.^[18] After a late goal from Nicky Forster gave the team a third consecutive league draw against Wycombe Wanderers, Flanagan told the press that "the sign of a good side is that they can roll their sleeves up and battle back."^[19]

Following their run of five consecutive league draws, which set a new club record,^[20] Gillingham were 18th in the 22-team league table.^[21] The team won their first league game of the season at the eighth attempt, defeating Scunthorpe United 1–0 on 25 September with a goal from Smillie.^[17] One week later, Gillingham gained their second league win of the season, defeating Carlisle United 2–1 with two goals from Forster despite Baker being sent off after less than 15 minutes; it was the first time the team had won away from home in the Football League since March 1992.^[22][23] The team's run of seven league games without defeat ended when they lost 1–0 away to Walsall on 9 October; Barrett was recalled to the team for the next game, in which Gillingham beat Darlington 2–1 at Priestfield with goals from Andy Arnott and Neil Smith to rise to 14th in the table.^[24] Gillingham's next game, away to Crewe Alexandra, resulted in a 1–0 defeat, but the team then won two consecutive home games, defeating Colchester United 3–0 and Hereford United 2–0.^[17][25] The two victories took the team up to 10th place in the table.^[26] Forster scored in both games, taking his total of league goals for the season to 7, more than any Gillingham player had achieved in the whole of the previous season.^[17][27]

Banks resumed the position of goalkeeper in early November and would remain in the starting line-up until April.^[28] Following the win over Hereford on 2 November, Gillingham lost four of the next five games and slipped to 17th in the division.^[29] The run included consecutive defeats in the first three matches of December against Lincoln City, Rochdale, and Chesterfield;^[17] against Rochdale Baker was sent off again.^[30] Forster scored Gillingham's second goal against Chesterfield, meaning that he had scored in six of the last seven league games.^[16] Gillingham ended their losing run in the final game of 1993 on 27 December, beating Northampton Town 1–0 at home with an own goal from Steve Terry; the attendance of 4,573 was the largest recorded at Priestfield during the season.^[31] The start of the match was delayed by 40 minutes as an electricity board worker had to be called out to disengage a timer switch which prevented the floodlights being turned on on weekday afternoons.^[32][33] Gillingham ended the year 17th in the table.^[34]

January–May

Gillingham began 1994 with a second consecutive 1–0 win at Priestfield, defeating Bury with a goal from Smillie on 1 January;^[17] the result took the team back up to 14th in the table.^[35] Two days later, Banks kept a third consecutive clean sheet as Gillingham drew 0–0 away to Doncaster; it was the first league game since October in which Gillingham failed to score a goal.^[17] Having failed to score in four consecutive games, Forster was relegated to the substitutes' bench for the game at home to Walsall on 22 January and was replaced in the starting line-up by Baker, who made his first appearance since before Christmas and scored in a 1–1 draw.^[28] Seven days later, Forster came off the bench to score the winning goal away to Colchester in the final minute of the game.^[16][36]

Forster once again came on as a substitute and scored in Gillingham's first match of February, a 3–1 defeat at home to Crewe.^[16] It was the first in a run of five league games in which Gillingham achieved no wins and scored only two goals.^[17] Forster returned to the starting line-up for the game away to Preston North End on 12 February but failed to score and the game finished goalless.^[16] The last game of February and the first of March both resulted in 1–0 defeats, at home to Wycombe and away to Chester City.^[17] Gillingham ended their winless run with a 1–0 win away to Torquay United on 5 March, but lost again seven days later away to Shrewsbury Town.^[17] The team had now not won at home in more than two months and had slipped to 15th in the table.^[37] In the final game of March, Forster scored for the first time in eight games as Gillingham defeated Carlisle 2–0 at Priestfield.^[16]

Gillingham began the month of April with a second consecutive victory, winning 2–1 away to Northampton, and followed this with two consecutive 2–2 draws at Priestfield, against Chester and Preston.^[17] Forster scored both goals against Preston, the second time that he had scored twice in a game; no other Gillingham player scored more than a single goal in a game during the season.^[17] Gillingham failed to score in the next two games; in the first of these games Gillingham's Tony Butler was sent off and Chris Pike scored two penalty kicks to give Hereford a 2–0 victory.^[38] Gillingham ended their winless run of four games when Forster scored the only goal of the game against Mansfield Town on 23 April.^[17] The final match of the season was a 1–1 draw at home to Lincoln; Richard Carpenter's goal was one of only two scored by Gillingham in the final five games of the season.^[17] Veteran former club captain Paul Clark was recalled to the team for the first time since January,^[28] and made what turned out to be his final appearance for the club.^[39] The result left Gillingham 16th in the final league table with 51 points, 13 points below the play-offs for potential promotion to the Second Division and 13 points above 22nd-placed Northampton, who were relegated from the Football League.^[40] Gillingham had the 12th best home record in the division but their overall position suffered from the fact that only two Third Division teams had a worse season away from home.^[41][42]

Match details

Key

Partial league table

FA Cup

As a Third Division team, Gillingham entered the 1993–94 FA Cup in the first round and were drawn to play away to Yeading of the Isthmian League Premier Division, two levels lower in the English football league system, who had progressed through four qualifying rounds to reach this stage of the competition for the first time.^[43][44] The game was played at Church Road, home of Yeading's local rivals Hayes, as the police deemed the crowd segregation facilities at Yeading's ground, The Warren, to be inadequate.^[45] Gillingham were held to a 0–0 draw by their semi-professional opponents, necessitating a replay at Priestfield.^[46][47] In the second match, Gillingham scored three goals in the first half and ultimately won 3–1.^[48] In the second round, Gillingham played away to Plymouth Argyle of the Second Division; Richard Green missed a penalty for Gillingham, who lost 2–0.^[30][49][50]

Football League Cup

As a Third Division team, Gillingham entered the 1993–94 Football League Cup in the first round and were paired with Brighton & Hove Albion of the Second Division. The first leg of the two-legged tie took place at Priestfield and Gillingham defeated their higher-level opponents 1–0 with a goal from Robbie Reinelt.^[53] Eight days later, however, Brighton won the second leg at the Goldstone Ground 2–0 and eliminated Gillingham from the competition by an aggregate score of 2–1.^[54]

Football League Trophy

The 1993–94 Football League Trophy, a tournament exclusively for Second and Third Division teams, began with a round in which the teams were drawn into groups of three, contested on a round-robin basis. Gillingham were grouped with fellow Third Division team Colchester United and Cambridge United of the Second Division. Gillingham's first group match was at home to Colchester in late September and resulted in a 0–0 draw;^[56] the attendance of 1,091 was the lowest recorded at Priestfield during the season.^[31] Five weeks later, Gillingham played their second group game away to Cambridge and lost 2–0.^[57] With only one point from the two games, Gillingham finished third in the group and failed to qualify for the second round, ending their participation in the competition.^[58]